In the past, we’ve covered a lot of lubes. However, now it’s time to cover the best lubes for fisting! Not only have we done our best to supply you with a list of the best fisting lubes but we’ve also put together the most important things to think about when buying a fisting lube.

We hope that this article will give you all the information you need to make the right decision. Let’s get into the post!

Top Picks:

Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream
Master Series Desensitizing Invade Deep Fisting Cream
Pjur Analyse Me Silicone Anal Lubricant
Wicked Anal Jelle Lubricant
Boy Butter Original
ID Glide Water-Based Lubricant
Sliquid Organics Natural Silk Hybrid Lubricant
Gun Oil H2O
Wet Uranus Silicone Anal Lubricant
Tom of Finland Fisting Formula

Show more

How to Choose The Best Lube for Fisting

Consistency

A thin and runny lubricant probably isn’t going to get the job done when it comes to fisting. It’s best to look for a thicker lube or at least one that provides you with a high level of lubrication.

Extra effects

Some lubes on our list have useful features like numbing or relaxing effects. This can make the whole experience a lot easier and a lot more pleasurable for both you and your partner.

Allergies

If you suffer from allergies it’s best to go with a lube that’s hypoallergenic and free from parabens. If you’re allergic to silicone, go with a lube that’s water or oil based to prevent you having any unwanted side effects.

Versatility

Some lubes are great for fisting, but others can be used for a wide range of other things too. A lube designed specifically for fisting may be a little better for that specific task but may fall short in other categories.

Luckily, we have enough versatile lubes on our list for you to choose from!

Best Lubes for Fisting:

Below, we’ve listed some of our top picks when it comes to fisting lubes. No matter your situation, we’re sure you’ll be able to find the right lube for you here!

Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream

The Triple Duty Fisting Cream That’s Good for More than Just Fisting

doc johnson titanmen water-based lube
We start the list off with the Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream, and it’s a great lube when it comes to fisting.

This lube isn’t made solely for fisting, but it was made with it in mind. This lube is also great for normal sex, as well as solo play. It boasts a long-lasting effect and allows you to keep on going well into the night!

When you first apply the lube, it’s very thick and creamy. However, as it warms up and is used, the lube becomes a little runnier and the consistency can be compared to that of normal lube.

This means that it’s great when you first get started, but as you continue to use it, it caters to your needs as well. It also comes in an extremely handy bottle with a simple to use pump. This allows for easy dispensing and makes it a delight to use.

The Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream is glycerin and paraben free which makes it great for people with sensitive skin and allergies. It’s priced on the lower end of this list making it a great addition to your lube collection.

Pros: Versatile lubricant, long-lasting effect, changes the texture to suit your needs, easy-to-use pump bottle, glycerin and paraben free

Cons: You need to apply quite a lot for it to last a long time

Master Series Desensitizing Invade Deep Fisting Cream

A Fisting Lube with a Desensitizing Effect

master series invade deep fisting cream
Second on the list is the Master Series Desensitizing Invade Deep Fisting Cream and it’s a model that packs a punch, as well as some handy features.

This lube works a charm! It’s long-lasting and lubricates you in the best way possible, preventing uncomfortable experiences. Its formula is a mixture of water-based lube, oil-based lube and silicone-based lube which gives it some of the best properties of all of these lubes.

As well as this, this lube offers you a rather special extra feature. It actually has a slight numbing effect which allows you to push it just that little bit further and prevents you from feeling any uncomfortable sensations when used.

The Master Series Desensitizing Invade Deep Fisting Cream is suitable for vegans and vegetarians. It’s priced in the high-mid price range compared to the other options on this list.

Pros: Long-lasting lubrication, mixture of multiple lube sorts, slight numbing effect

Cons: Not condom compatible

Pjur Analyse Me Silicone Anal Lubricant

The Lube with a Relaxing Effect

pjur analyse me
The third option we have for you is the Pjur Analyse Me Silicone Anal Lubricant, and even though it’s marketed as an anal lubricant, it has some nifty features that make it a real contender for the best lube for fisting.

This anal lube is a great option when it comes to fisting. It boasts a relaxing effect which makes the whole experience a lot easier and a whole lot more fun. This also makes fisting much more pleasurable due to the fact that the anal muscles are more relaxed.

As well as the relaxing effect, it also contains jojoba extract which has a softening effect on your skin. This not only helps make the experience a lot easier, but it also makes the sensation much more pleasurable.

The Pjur Analyse Me Silicone Anal Lubricant is extremely potent, and just a few drops will last a long time. It’s on the slightly more expensive side of the list though.

Pros: Great for both anal and vaginal fisting, relaxing effect, softening effect on the skin, extremely potent

Cons: Not compatible with most condoms

Wicked Anal Jelle Lubricant

The Water-Based Fisting Lube that Works With Toys and Condoms

wicked aqua jelle anal personal lubricant
Next on the list is the Wicked Anal Jelle Lubricant. This is another great option when it comes to fisting lube and boasts a wide range of features.

This water-based fisting lube is great in all situation. Since it’s water-based, it can be used in conjunction with condoms as well as sex toys which makes it a dynamic addition to your nightstand.

Even though it’s water based, it still has a thicker consistency which makes it a great option for anal, as well as fisting. The thicker consistency makes the experience go much smoother and a whole lot more pleasurable.

The formula that this lube uses is glycerin free and doesn’t get sticky or tacky when used. It’s also long-lasting which prevents you from having to halt your fun to reapply every few minutes.

The Wicked Anal Jelle Lubricant is on the cheaper end of this list which makes it extremely accessible. With all of its features, it’s surely a great option for you to choose from!

Pros: water-based, compatible with toys and condoms, thick consistency, glycerin free, doesn’t go sticky or tacky, long-lasting, great value

Cons: Doesn’t offer any extravagant features like relaxing or numbing effect

Boy Butter Original

The Lube with a Vegetable and Coconut Oil Blend

boy butter original
Next on the list is the Boy Butter Original which is another very different option compared to the previous options on this list.

This lube, unlike the other options, is an oil-based lubricant which comes with its own advantages. The coconut and vegetable oil blend makes it a great lubricant that’s very long-lasting.

This lube is great for massages and is also an ideal lube for use in the tub or shower. Due to the fact it’s oil based, it doesn’t wash off easily during use which makes it great for times like these.

It’s also non-staining which enables you to use it without any worries about your sheets getting ruined. The long-lasting effect combined with the strong lubrication that this lube provides makes it great for fisting.

The Boy Butter Original is an organic lubricant which is priced in the middle of the pack compared to the other models on this list.

Pros: Unique lubricant, long-lasting lubrication, great for massages, great for use in the tub or shower, non-staining, long lasting, organic

Cons: Can’t be used together with condoms or most sex toys

ID Glide Water-Based Lubricant

Lube Rated as the Number One Lube by Men’s Health

id glide natural feel water based lube
The ID Glide Water-Based Lubricant is next on the list and it’s another large bottle that provides great lubrication.

This lube is rather special and of extremely good quality. It was actually rated as the number one lube by Men’s Health Magazine! This just goes to show the quality of this lube and how effective it is.

It’s clear which prevents staining and is completely odorless too which prevents nasty smells when using the lube. As well as these things, this lube is water-based which makes it compatible with all condoms and sex toys and a great addition to your bedside cabinet.

The ID Glide provides a smooth experience and provides long-lasting lubrication. It was designed with sex in mind and helps to make the whole experience a lot more pleasurable.

It’s one of the less-expensive lubes on this list, making it extremely accessible. A great value lube that suits just about anyone.

Pros: Quality lube, award-winning, clear, odorless, compatible with sex toys and condoms, smooth experience, great value

Cons: The bottle is a squeeze bottle and not a pump which can get a little messy

Sliquid Organics Natural Silk Hybrid Lubricant

The Organic Fisting Lube

sliquid organics natural silk hybrid lubricant
If you’re looking for something more natural and with a lot of features, then the Sliquid Organics Natural Silk Hybrid Lubricant is a great option for you.

This lube is extremely silky which makes it feel great on your skin. The luxurious feel combined with the infused natural ingredients really make this product stand out.

Its formula also includes aloe vera and is a wonderful lube for people with sensitive skin. The calming green tea extracts help to provide you with a relaxing sensation and make the whole experience even more pleasurable.

This lube is great for sensual massages, as well as for use during sex. The formula is long-lasting and provides more than sufficient lubrication when it comes to fisting. The vitamin E that’s added to the lube also helps to moisturize and repair your skin.

The Sliquid Organics Natural Silk Hybrid Lubricant is vegan-friendly and organic, making it a great option for animal lovers too. It’s one of the less expensive models on this list which makes it of extremely great value.

Pros: Silky smooth lubrication, luxurious feel, long-lasting formula, great for people with sensitive skin, vegan-friendly, organic, great value

Cons: the bottle isn’t very user-friendly

Gun Oil H2O

High-Quality Lube that Enhances Natural Moisture

gun oil h2o water based lube
With high-standards and great lubrication, the Gun Oil H2O is next on the list and it’s one we couldn’t leave out!

They placed all of their focus on quality with this lube. Not only does it do the job extremely well, but it also boasts various healing and moisturizing properties due to the aloe vera extract it contains.

It also enhances natural moisture to make fisting a whole lot easier. This also prevents both parties from getting too lubed up and prevents sticky messes during use.

Ginseng and guarana are two of the other ingredients that this lube contains. This helps to boost energy levels and make the sex a whole lot pleasurable. All this and it’s still odorless and flavorless to ensure a great experience.

The Gun Oil H2O lube is easy to clean and compatible with pretty much all toys and condoms. It’s also one of the less expensive options on this list.

Pros: Contains aloe vera for moisturization, enhances natural lubrication, improves sexual experience, odorless, flavorless, easy to clean

Cons: Doesn’t offer any numbing or relaxing effects which can be useful for fisting

Wet Uranus Silicone Anal Lubricant

The Extra-Thick Lube that’s Great for Fisting

wet uranus silicone personal lubricant
Second to last on the list is the Wet Uranus Silicone Anal Lubricant, and it’s another lube designed to handle the more extreme bedroom activities.

This lube was specifically designed with anal in mind. The added thickness and extra-strong lubrication make it an ideal lube for fisting too though. It was made to handle more extravagant bedroom activities.

This lube is actually an FDA-approved which gives you peace of mind when using it. This ensures you get quality and won’t experience any unforeseen issues during use.

The Wet Uranus Silicone Anal Lubricant is compatible with condoms and all sex toys which aren’t made of silicone. It’s one of the less-expensive options on this list, making it a great value if you’re looking for high-quality fisting lube.

Pros: Extra thick, strong lubrication, FDA approved, compatible with condoms and non-silicone sex toys

Cons: Contains glycerine

Tom of Finland Fisting Formula

The Ultimate Fisting Lube With All the Features

tom of finland fisting formula
Last but not least is the Tom of Finland Fisting Formula, and we may have just left the best for last!

This lube was designed specifically for fisting and does the job extremely well. Not only does it lubricate to the next level, but it also contains a slight relaxing agent which helps to relax your muscles and make the experience a whole lot more pleasurable.

This relaxing agent helps you push your limits and enjoy the experience like never before. It also includes a slight numbing agent which helps to make the whole experience even easier.

If you’re looking for a lube that will really give you an advantage when it comes to fisting, then the Tom of Finland Fisting Formula is a great option for you. It’s on the less-expensive end of this list too which makes it a great value!

Pros: Made specifically for fisting, offers both a relaxing as well as a numbing effect, great value

Cons: Not hypoallergenic like some of the other models

FAQ’s:

Are there any tips you have for a beginner on this topic?

Of course there are, and it starts with using enough lube. Without lube, it can be quite a bad experience and can even be painful. Another tip is to warm up and not dive straight in.

Your body needs time to get used to the sensation and stretch out. Start with a dildo or some fingers and gradually build up. Slow and steady wins the race!

How can I make fisting more pleasurable?

Answering this question would take a whole new article. Luckily though, Cosmopolitan has a great beginners guide to fisting which contains a lot of tips and tricks on the topic!

Are there any other lubes you recommend?

Of course there are! Check out our article on the best lubes and lubes for anal if you’re interested in other fantastic options when it comes to lubing up!

Conclusion

Fisting can be great fun but having the right lube for fisting will really help you to experience the optimal amount of pleasure. After reading this article, you should be well on your way to finding the best fisting lube for you.

Who knows, you may have already found what you’re looking for… Remember to have fun and stay safe!